top of page
    Search

    Passion is a High Bar. An Interview with Carli Fink

    emmatompkins6
    6 days ago
    7 min read

    This post was created entirely without the use of generative AI tools. All research, writing, and revisions are my own. Statements and quotes from Carli Fink are based on an interview conducted on November 6, 2026, and are published with her explicit permission.



    When I surveyed 60 people about passion (I Asked 60 People About Passion.), I hoped for a pattern, or a formula that would help me figure it out for myself. Mostly I got confirmation of something I already kind of suspected: passion is abstract, and it means something different to everyone.


    The results didn't settle anything for me. If anything, they kicked off my existential dread spiral even more, and my own circle validated it, with plenty of them seemingly feeling the same way. Does passion need to show up at work? Some people said yes, but noted it can also live in a hobby, a side project, or family and friends. Others said not necessarily, but then contradicted themselves by saying they'd take a pay cut to have passion show up in their work.


    I was left feeling confused, and part of me wanted to give up on the whole question and accept that having a job is enough. Truthfully, the whole internal debate started to feel a bit privileged. Wanting your work to light you up is a beautiful thing to want. It's also a luxury, and I'm not writing this from the side of people who can afford it. I can't quit my job to chase a feeling, or take a pay cut in the name of passion.


    But I also don't want that to be my cop-out. Even as a certified pessimist, I don't think it's the dead end it sounds like. 


    Realizing it was time to stop going in circles within my own echo chamber, I decided to step outside of it.


    I started a conversation with Carli Fink.


    Meet Carli

    I wanted to interview a career development professional, a true expert in the field. What could someone who hears these questions every day tell me? But more than anything, I wanted someone who understood the human side. Realistically, my spiral is grounded more in sociology and psychology, in the questions about why we work and who we are, rather than wanting to better understand a standard checklist on how to land a job or improve my resume.


    Carli is a Certified Career Development Practitioner with a background in psychology, which is a big part of why her work stood out to me. She spent about six years as a career counsellor at universities, helping students with the classic “what do I do with this degree?” question.


    A little over a year ago, she left her full-time job in workforce development to build what she calls a portfolio career: three part-time roles at once. She runs her own career counselling and education practice called Foreseeable Futures, where she works with adults going through career transitions and with high schools and youth organizations (Foreseeable Futures Career Consultancy | Toronto & Online). She teaches career development in U of T's Bachelor of Information program. And she works with the Challenge Factory, a consultancy firm that does workforce research and advisory work for companies and governments.


    Carli’s path resisted the straight line. She went to Queen's University to study drama, took linguistics because it sounded cool, and ended up in first-year psychology because it was one of the only courses with room left. Then she spent her twenties hopping between jobs, on purpose. “I wanted to do all of the things, and I couldn't possibly choose between them,” she said. So she did them one after another, until she got exhausted and decided that wasn't sustainable.


    Listening to her, I felt a sharp ache of recognition. Funny enough, we share a very similar mosaic of interests: a love for musical theatre, a deep curiosity about psychology without the desire to become therapists, and a passion for education without the urge to manage a classroom. We are both drawn to community building and the outdoors. We both considered a career in journalism and writing, only to be steered towards marketing and communications by the well-meaning chorus of voices promising “professional stability”. 


    Yet, beneath all the shared interests, there’s a fundamental divergence. Carli’s zigzag was fuelled by abundance; she was pulled so fiercely by every interest that she had to try them all. My zigzag, I think, comes from a quieter, more paralyzing space. I have plenty of interests, but none of them possess the gravity to pull me toward a career. Which... is the reason I started this blog in the first place. 


    The question that surprised me

    To get right into it, the biggest surprise came when I asked how often the word “passion” comes up in her work. Carli's answer was "not much."


    “Frankly, I don't find it comes up that much in my work,” she told me. It's not the question driving most of the adults she works with. What she hears most now is some version of: “how can I make my work life work for me?” People come to her knowing what they can do. What's missing is a higher income, more stability, a less intense pace, or more flexible hours. They want to design their work around the life they've built, “rather than treating my job as if it lives in a vacuum.”


    That said, she recognized that passion does occasionally come up with two groups. The first is people who already have a specific passion, often a creative one, and want to figure out how to earn an income while pursuing it. The second is high school students, who've been told passion should be the first filter for every career decision. She told me that she had actually run workshops for grade 9 and grade 10 students that same week. “One of the great joys of my work is telling people it doesn't have to be that way.”


    Honestly, I felt a little called out. Here I was, treating passion as the question, and the person who sits with career questions all day was telling me most people aren't even asking it.


    Passion is a high bar

    When I told her what I'd heard growing up (if you're stuck, think about what you like, what you're interested in, what you're passionate about), she stopped me. "Those are three different questions. They overlap, because they’re all about reflecting on yourself. But they aren't interchangeable terms.”


    Passion, she said, holds people to a high bar. “It puts a lot of pressure on a choice,” as if, unless you feel as strongly as you possibly could about something, it isn't good enough to even start. That pressure stops people from trying things they might like, be good at, or just be curious about, where passion could grow over time. “And if it doesn't grow, a fulfilling career and a sustainable income still might.”


    She pointed me to a book: So Good They Can't Ignore You by Cal Newport, a computer scientist at Georgetown University who interviewed people who are deeply passionate about their work. His finding, as Carli summed it up: for many of them, passion came second. It showed up once they got really good at something and reached the point of doing work worth being passionate about. 


    That reframed my privilege worry. If passion is something you have to find first and then afford to chase, I'm out. If it's something that builds as you get good at something, it isn't reserved for people who can quit.


    Carli was also clear that not everyone needs it. “Some people want work that lights them up and will take a pay cut and some instability to get it. Others decide they care more about contentment, a stable routine and a sustainable income. If somebody wants passion in their job, that's great. If somebody else doesn't, that's also perfectly fine with me.”


    Hobby, job, career, vocation

    I admitted that comparison fuels a lot of my spiral. I look at friends who are teachers and nurses, people who seem to love what they do, while making a real difference, and then wonder if I'm doing enough, or missing something entirely.


    Carli's response was kind but direct. She knows a lot of teachers and nurses, and said “I wouldn't be so quick to assume they all love their jobs all the time.” Fair point. Moving on.


    Then she shared a breakdown she's used in workshops, from a video by Elizabeth Gilbert, the author of Eat, Pray, Love. Gilbert separates terms people tend to lump together. A hobby is something that you do purely for pleasure. A job is something you do to earn an income, and almost everyone needs one. A career is the bigger umbrella: jobs that build on each other toward a larger goal, and realistically, something you should love. Not everyone needs a career, and some people are genuinely satisfied with a job. A vocation, however, is a sense of calling or purpose, the “I have to do this kind of work". It's the closest thing to what we usually mean by passion, and it's common in frontline roles like teaching and nursing (Acumen Academy, 2017). 


    Having a vocation is great, Carli said, but you might not need one. If the pull comes from inside you, it may be a sign to try different things, stick with something and see if a sense of vocation develops. But sometimes “the pressure to find your calling comes from outside, not from anything you actually need.”


    That one landed. How much of my spiral is mine, and how much of it is comparison?


    Diagnose before you treat

    Before we wrapped up, I asked what advice she gives most often. Her answer was to separate out the different parts of your career before deciding what's wrong.


    She uses a simple framework of five areas to probe when someone feels dissatisfied. People often arrive sure that their job or their whole field is the problem. Dig in, and it might be their boss. A move to another team at the same company could fix what they thought needed a full career overhaul. “I really try to diagnose the problem before treating it.”


    Where I landed

    I went into this conversation half hoping an expert would give me the map that I so desperately wanted to find my passion. Instead, she gave me permission to stop treating it as the first filter.


    For a long time, I treated my zigzag path as a bit of a personal flaw, the inability to pick a lane and stick to it. Carli helped me realize that lowering the bar from an all consuming passion down to basic curiosity makes the whole thing feel a lot less daunting. I don’t need a job that defines my entire identity, I just need one that leaves me enough room to live it.



    Sources 

    Acumen Academy. (2017). Elizabeth Gilbert on distinguishing between hobbies, jobs, careers, & vocation [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0g7ARarFNnw

    Fink, C. (n.d.). Foreseeable Futures. https://www.foreseeablefutures.ca/

    Newport, C. (2012). So good they can't ignore you: Why skills trump passion in the quest for work you love. Grand Central Publishing.


     
     
     

    Recent Posts

    See All

    Comments


    bottom of page